Why is legal writing so rigid?
Updated: Nov 11
Many new law students are frustrated by what they see as the overly rigid constraints of legal writing and the CREAC format. What I tell students: learning legal writing is like learning to bake. When you first learn to bake, you have to follow a recipe very closely because you have no idea what you are doing. If you try to innovate, you’ll end up with something no one wants to eat.
Over time, as you learn more about baking, you’ll see how you adjust things to your preferences. You can substitute pecans for walnuts or omit the nuts altogether. You can make the cookies larger if you adjust the oven time. And so on. You learn that there is room for flexibility, but the basic tenets of baking remain the same.
Learning CREAC (or whatever your preferred acronym) is just like learning to bake. In the fall semester, your professor wants you to stick very closely to this structure because if you don’t, you’ll end up with a jumbled mess.
Later on, you’ll see that there is more freedom within the CREAC structure than it seems right now. But all good attorneys will still follow some basic conventions, including that an author must first tell the reader what the law is (the R/E section) before explaining how that law applies to the given facts (the A section). Once you've mastered the basics, your professor will loosen the reins a bit. Trust the process.
Alyssa Dragnich is a law school professor with more than 15 years of experience teaching legal writing and academic success classes. More about Alyssa. Free law school resources. Get in touch. Follow @jdwithadhd on Instagram.

Comments